How does declawing benefit a cat’s health?
Friday, August 28th, 2009I know that spaying and neutering have health benefits for cats. It helps prevents cancers and removes the urges that cause them to roam and fight, among other things.
However, I have yet to discover what benefits declawing contributes to a cat’s health. So, my question is what does declawing do to benefit the cat?
So, if there is no benefit to the cat, then why would people do it their cats?
Surely it couldn’t be for selfish reasons, could it?
I would like to hear from people who believe there are benefits to the cat. Or, perhaps there aren’t any?
I’m having a hard time buying into the whole ‘rather have my fingers amputated than not live at all’ reasoning. Humans in civilized cultures would never have to face that decision. Amputation for anything other than a severe medical condition would be considered torture by any reasonable society and the offender would surely be prosecuted. You can’t tell me that having the tips of your fingers cut off would not have some negative impact on your well being.
This comment is for those wondering why I would ask this question when I’ve clearly indicated my views against declawing in other posts. The answer is simple. I think it is healthy for people to challenge their own viewpoints occassionally, especially those we feel very strongly about. I don’t want to fall into the trap of being so strongheaded about something that I fail to consider other possibilities. In this case, I wanted to make sure that I was not blindly missing some beneficial things. After all, declawing is legal in the US so I figured there might be good reason.
Based on the responses I’ve seen here, I think I’ll stay with my current viewpoint. However, one answer has a scenario I hadn’t considered before and I do agree that in that particular situation, declawing actually did benefit a cat’s health.
Rodney








